5 Reasons Why NYC's Pay Phone Wifi Plan Won't Replace Traditional ISPs

Updated on: January 12, 2019

You, along with most of the world, may have completely forgotten about pay phones. Well, with its 12,000 still-standing phone booths, New York City certainly hasn't. The city government has decided that these outdated machines need revamping, and they've chosen to do this by providing the phones with free Wi-Fi.

This may sound like a good idea at first. After all everybody likes free things, and everyone loves the Internet, so it seems like a no-brainer. And it's better to put those phone booths to use; nobody wants a bunch of seemingly useless eye-sores all over their city.


But the question real is, will people actually use this free phone-booth Wi-Fi in favour of traditional ISPs? Probably not, and here are 5 good reasons why.

1. It's Too Slow

Most people want fast Internet when it comes to using portable devices. It kind of comes with the "on-the-go" feel that phones, tablets, and laptops offer. But, according to NPR, it's not going to be  as fast as you might hope. Having to stop and stand at a booth and wait around for your Internet to work probably sounds unappealing to most people.

slow internet

In fact one article states that it can take up to 2-3 minutes — a relatively long time in the online world — just to get fully connected to the Internet . It would seem that the Wi-Fi systems would have great potential for signal strength, seeing as you can stand right next to it, but according to the article, it's "extremely weak."

2. You Have to Find Somewhere to Sit

Pay phones weren't built assuming most users would be making long-lasting phone calls. Thus, unless you want to be on your feet, you have to find somewhere to sit within its reach.


Otherwise, you'll be stuck standing holding your tablet, laptop, or your phone in front of your face until you've achieved your online goal for the moment. But be careful, because the farther you get, the weaker the signal will be.

3. There's Little Demand

These days, endless options exist for Internet access. With many businesses offering Wi-Fi connections, on top of the countless ISP companies offering cheap internet services, it doesn't seem as if people are begging for the ability to get free internet anywhere at anytime.

less demand

Many traditional ISP companies today, such as EarthLink, provide such cheap options that it leaves little incentive for folks to use the payphone's Wi-Fi. The system doesn't give great service for anything data-heavy to begin with, so it won't save you in that area.

4. It's Unsecured

Information sent over unsecured wi-fi networks can easily land in the wrong hands. Again, Wi-Fi and internet access aren't hard to find, so why risk using an unsecured network outdoors?


While it's not incredibly dangerous, it leaves little appeal when most other options are free from this risk. And even though the system has no password security, it won't fail to annoy you by sending you to a terms and conditions page where you must agree to gain access.

5. What's New About This?

This might prove the biggest issue: there's simply no innovation here. Today's tech industry values innovative and unique ideas, loaded with user-friendly functionality. While Wi-Fi using the existing payphone infrastructure has not been done before, nobody actually invented anything, or provided an unprecedented service. It's just the same service offered by companies like NetZero and Juno, only lower quality and available in more spots.

It may seem like a cool idea, but without improvements and some sort of innovation, these Wi-Fi spots are unlikely to replace the services we've become accustomed to. Traditional ISPs can rest easy, because New York City's "innovation" poses no threat whatsoever to them.

Post Tags: #internet nyc #nyc wifi #pay phone wifi
Saurabh Mukhekar
Saurabh Mukhekar is a Professional Tech Blogger. World Traveler. He is also thinker, maker, life long learner, hybrid developer, edupreneur, mover & shaker. He's captain planet of BlogSaays and seemingly best described in rhyme. Follow Him On Facebook

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Fire it up! Nice article and will hang a bit and check out your other posts. It is always a professional ability to maintain your websites and love the work at the same time. Can be a tedious task and when you go forward with this profession - I will know a little bit more than I did with you as I am in presence with my ayahuasca healing forum and love the work! Namaste

Share via
Copy link